What a great find! We were looking for a place to have a late lunch at a place we hadn't been before. After searching the Internet, we decided to give One Eyed Willy's a shot. We were pleasantly surprised that it had a great varied menu that offered Seafood, house-made Barbecue, Hamburgers, Hotdogs and more. I had a buttery lobster roll loaded with tender juicy lobster and was served with crispy French fries and onion rings and wonderful house made coleslaw. My husband had a huge juicy cheeseburger and a tasty chili dog, both of which were very flavorful. Our food was very good, and we could hear all of the people sitting near us "ooo-ing and ahh-ing" about how good their food was ... and it all looked delicious! The place is quite small with only a few tables, but they also have a couple of high-tops and counter service ... and a full bar! Everything was clean, freshly renovated and tastefully decorated, and the cheerful service was excellent! And .. the food was very reasonably priced! We definitely will be going back again!

Always the best food and I can't speak more highly of the customer service I get from Mike the owner. Really great guy who cares about his customers. As a former chef, customers are your #1 priority. Thanks mike for good food and customer service. . I wish this customer service here was everywhere. Thanks again mike. Keep up the good food and service.

A loved local establishment that I think Meriden needed. They offer seafood, BBQ, burgers, and breakfast. They also have a bar and a decent amount of seating inside and outside. I think it's interesting when a restaurant offers many options, but I hope they don't lose the essence of being a seafood restaurant. I've tried quite a few things here, but the fried clam strips, whole bellies, and fried shrimp have never missed for me. I'm not big on lobster rolls, but it's next on my list to try! It's great to not have to drive to the coast for seafood. I give them 5 stars because of Chef Mills. I've liked the Pig Mac sandwich, smoked kielbasa, coleslaw, and I love the cornbread, but didn't like the ribs another day I went. It could have just been the day I went, but I was so shy to let him know, and he fixed it for me. He genuinely wants you to like his food and seems like such a nice guy. He said he's been tweaking the recipe, and I'd be happy to give it another chance because of him.

The restaurant is small, but the portions are good size. Never been disappointed. I agree!!

Fast , fresh and local .not to mention the bar section is more than (good selections ) expected . I will be returning with more mouths to feed .

Fantastic food, great local beer on tap and a welcoming atmosphere! The brisket was by FAR the best I've had...and that's topping other local bbq places.

I ordered for pick-up. There's a small lot in the back, but there's also street parking on the side street. I called in the order to be picked up at 5. The person on the phone was pleasant. It's small inside, but there are tables and a bar. I didn't take photos, as people were dining. I wanted to try a couple of different things, so I ordered the garlic knot lobster rolls, fried shrimp platter that comes with cole slaw and fries, and two cornbreads. Everything ordered was very good! The fried shrimp were surprisingly big and juicy. Those are always hit-or-miss. The next time I go, I'll get the regular lobster roll. The garlic knot one was okay, but I think I'd like the roll better. I'd even consider getting the fried shrimp again. The cole slaw was also good. It's nice having a seafood spot here in Meriden. There's plenty on the menu to choose from!

This is our third time here, Food was great, the lobster roll had just the perfect amount of butter, not too much and not too little. The fries had a nice tasting seasoning in them. The steak sandwich was fresh sliced steak, not some pre sliced "steak-um's" like most places. It came with American cheese and we asked for the liquid golden cheese as well, perfect combination, the roll was soft and held its own amongst the gooey cheese. This would be 5 stars based on the food but the "waitress" we felt should be in another business, she had an attitude and had a snotty attitude. When we stated we didn't like the spicy white sauce that normally comes on the steak grinder and requested the golden cheese sauce she got an attitude stating that is how it is served according to the menu, we had told her that we were previously told we could ask for the golden cheese, and not the spicy white one, she didn't seem happy at all, it was like she couldn't be bothered to place an order that is different than what was on the menu. Then when she brought over the sweet tea gave a big sigh when I asked for a straw like I should just drink out of the mason jar that it is served in. This was out first experience with this "waitress" and hopefully our last because a small establishment like this can not afford to have an employee with this attitude. This is a a great little place a Sam all hole in the wall place that makes it feel like your local neighborhood eatery where you are always greeted by the owner and the food is fantastic.

We have been back many times since my first review. Now there is a new menu with more items. Everything has been excellent. The quantity of food is great. They are still very busy, sometimes a little bit of a wait, but it is worth waiting for. We haven't had a chance to eat in the dining room, soon I hope to have the time. The service is great even under all the pressure of a crowd. Everyone is very pleasant. I'm posting new pictures of the menu. They have specials sometimes that pop up. They also have some tables and umbrellas outside to sit at. I highly recommend eating here.